Dumb Phone PickerPhone selection guide · United States · Rev. 11.26

Compare side by side

Pick up to four. Every cell shows its source and the date we checked it.

FieldDumbphone 2 (dumb.co)Light Phone III
TypeMinimalist phoneMinimalist phone
Price$20$899
First-year cost$211.88 (incl. 12 × $15.99 plan)$899
Verizonno (Locked to dumb.co's own SIM and plan; other SIMs are not supported.) source · 2026-11-02partial (Light's checker (Light III/Flip unlocked model, data updated 2026-10-21) lists 'Verizon (certification in progress)'. Light's Light III intro article: an already-active Verizon SIM works, but new Verizon lines can't be activated on the phone yet; eSIM not yet on Verizon. Asked when certification will be done, Light support's email reply to Elizabeth, Oct 26, 2026 (company statement, not independent verification): "Should be complete by the end of the year." Until then, treat as partial.) source · 2026-10-26
AT&Tno (Locked to dumb.co's own SIM and plan; other SIMs are not supported.) source · 2026-11-02yes (Listed compatible on Light's checker. Also works per Light: Light service, Mint, Noble Mobile, US Mobile (Light Speed only).) source · 2026-10-26
T-Mobileyes (Spec sheet: "carrier T-Mobile", via dumb.co's plan only.) source · 2026-11-02yes (Listed compatible. Light lists Metro by T-Mobile, Google Fi and most other MVNOs as not compatible.) source · 2026-10-26
VoLTEUnknownYes (Per Light support's email reply to Elizabeth, Oct 26, 2026 (company statement, not independent verification): VoLTE "Yes" on Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile. Light's public pages (linked checker, help center) don't state VoLTE; the link is Light's official carrier page.) source · 2026-10-26
Shapeflip (Modified TCL Flip 2.) source · 2026-11-02bar source · 2026-10-24
Display2.8" (Plus 1.44" outer screen for caller ID and time.) source · 2026-11-023.92" matte AMOLED, 1080x1240 source · 2026-10-24
Battery (mAh)1850 source · 2026-11-021800 source · 2026-10-24
Weight (g)140 source · 2026-11-02124 source · 2026-10-24
Camera (MP)2 source · 2026-11-0250 (50MP rear sensor, 12MP default output; 8MP front.) source · 2026-10-24
SoftwaredumbOS (modified TCL Flip 2) source · 2026-11-02LightOS source · 2026-10-24
Headphone jackYes source · 2026-11-02No (USB-C port works with wired USB-C headphones.) source · 2026-10-24
HotspotYes source · 2026-11-02Yes source · 2026-10-26
MapsYes source · 2026-11-02Yes (Directions tool.) source · 2026-10-24
App storeUnknown (No app store mentioned; FAQ says sideloading is not supported.)No (No app store; optional LightOS tools plus a developer program for community tools.) source · 2026-10-24
WhatsApp / SignalUnknownNo (No Signal or WhatsApp currently.) source · 2026-10-24
Water/dustUnknownIP54 source · 2026-10-24
Uber / LyftYesYes
WhatsAppWorkaroundNo
SignalWorkaroundNo
Banking / 2FAWorkaroundWorkaround
iMessageWorkaroundUnknown
Tap to payNoNo
Web browserUnknownNo
No web browserUnknownYes
Parental controlsUnknownUnknown
Location sharingUnknownUnknown

Written comparisons

  1. Light Phone III vs Light Flip: Which Light Phone to Get

    Light Phone III ($899, bar) vs Light Flip ($349, flip, ships 2027): screen, headphone jack, weight, carriers and availability from Light's pages, Oct 2026.

  2. Light Phone III vs Mudita Kompakt: Specs, Price, Carriers

    Light Phone III ($899, OLED, 5G pre-order) vs Mudita Kompakt ($399, E Ink): screen, battery, weight, carriers and what each leaves out, as of Oct 2026.

The occasional letter

One short email when a phone worth knowing about comes out. Unsubscribe any time.

Sign up for the newsletter

Privacy