Dumb Phone PickerPhone selection guide · United States · Rev. 11.26

Compare side by side

Pick up to four. Every cell shows its source and the date we checked it.

FieldMudita KompaktSunbeam F1 Pro
TypeMinimalist phoneFeature phone
Price$399$359
First-year costPlan costs not yet verifiedPlan costs not yet verified
Verizonyes (Mudita's store FAQ: its tests in Chicago, Detroit and Orlando 'confirmed that the Global version of Mudita Kompakt works with major networks like AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon'; the North America version is FCC/PTCRB certified. Activation tip from Mudita's community manager (forum.mudita.com, July 2025): if a new Verizon SIM won't activate, activate it first in a phone already on Verizon's network, then move it. No MVNO list published.) source · 2026-11-01yes (Verizon Retail: calls, SMS, MMS, hotspot, Wi-Fi calling, visual voicemail all marked working. Many Verizon MVNOs also work (Tracfone, Straight Talk, Total, US Mobile Warp, Page Plus); Visible, Xfinity, Spectrum and SafeLink do not. Sunbeam support: 'Sunbeam phones are unlocked and work with any compatible carrier.') source · 2026-11-01
AT&Tyes source · 2026-10-26yes (AT&T: calls, SMS, MMS work; hotspot, Wi-Fi calling and Wi-Fi texting marked not working. Cricket, Consumer Cellular, H2O, PureTalk, US Mobile Dark Star work.) source · 2026-11-01
T-Mobileyes source · 2026-10-26yes (T-Mobile Retail: all features marked working. F1 Pro spec sheet (Aug 2026) lists LTE B71; the old 'missing band 71' note applied to the original F1. Mint, Tello, Metro, US Mobile Light Speed work.) source · 2026-11-01
VoLTEYes (Mudita lists 'Voice over LTE' and Wi-Fi calling for both the North America and Global versions.) source · 2026-10-26Yes (Sunbeam's Jan 2025 / Oct 2024 F1 Pro updates 'Enabled VoLTE by default for all carriers'. Corroborated by Verizon Open Development listing (VoLTE/HD Voice).) source · 2026-10-24
Shapebar source · 2026-10-24flip source · 2026-10-24
Display4.3" E Ink touchscreen, 800x480 source · 2026-10-242.8", 480x640 source · 2026-10-24
Battery (mAh)3300 source · 2026-10-242200 source · 2026-10-24
Weight (g)164 source · 2026-10-24187 source · 2026-10-24
Camera (MP)8 source · 2026-10-245 (Camera models only.) source · 2026-10-24
SoftwareMuditaOS K (de-Googled AOSP) source · 2026-10-24BasicOS source · 2026-10-24
Headphone jackYes source · 2026-10-24Yes source · 2026-10-24
HotspotYes (Mudita support: "Yes, you can set up a hot spot" (Wi-Fi hotspot; article modified 2026-10-03).) source · 2026-10-26Yes (Juniper, Aspen, Maple, Cypress and Walnut models only. No hotspot on Spruce, Hickory, Redwood, Birch, Oak, Elm, Pine, Cedar, Willow or Poplar (2026 spec sheet; Walnut/Poplar from their product pages).) source · 2026-11-01
MapsYes (Offline maps.) source · 2026-10-24Yes (Waze on Juniper, Spruce, Aspen, Hickory, Walnut and Poplar; Here navigation also on Maple and Oak; Cypress, Redwood, Birch, Elm, Pine, Cedar and Willow have no navigation. Navigation features need a Sunbeam subscription (spec-sheet footnote).) source · 2026-11-01
App storeNo ("Mudita Kompakt does not include an app store"; Android apps can be sideloaded via the Mudita Center desktop app.) source · 2026-10-26No (Every F1 Pro model: 'does NOT have: Any Google apps, Web browser, Social Media apps, App Store' (same list on the Aspen, Walnut and Poplar pages).) source · 2026-11-01
WhatsApp / SignalNo (Mudita support (modified 2026-10-03): the Kompakt 'does not include a dedicated messaging app like WhatsApp or Signal' and 'There is no app store on the Mudita Kompakt to install third-party apps.' Android APKs can be sideloaded via Mudita Center with no compatibility guarantee (apps.whatsapp and apps.signal = workaround).) source · 2026-11-01No (No WhatsApp or Signal app is named. Walnut and Poplar ($389, in stock) add Dewdrop, 'our in-house messaging app that allows users to message other Dewdrop and Signal users'. Both list text and picture messaging and say the phones cannot send or receive RCS.) source · 2026-11-07
Water/dustIP54 source · 2026-10-24Unknown (No IP or MIL-STD rating published. Sunbeam support: the F1 Pro is 'a durable, water/dust resistant device' but 'is not considered "waterproof" and water damage is not covered by warranty' (checked 2026-11-01).)
Uber / LyftWorkaroundUnknown
WhatsAppWorkaroundNo
SignalWorkaroundNo
Banking / 2FAWorkaroundUnknown
iMessageUnknownUnknown
Tap to payUnknownUnknown
Web browserUnknownUnknown
No web browserUnknownUnknown
Parental controlsUnknownUnknown
Location sharingUnknownUnknown

Written comparisons

  1. Light Phone III vs Light Flip: Which Light Phone to Get

    Light Phone III ($899, bar) vs Light Flip ($349, flip, ships 2027): screen, headphone jack, weight, carriers and availability from Light's pages, Oct 2026.

  2. Light Phone III vs Mudita Kompakt: Specs, Price, Carriers

    Light Phone III ($899, OLED, 5G pre-order) vs Mudita Kompakt ($399, E Ink): screen, battery, weight, carriers and what each leaves out, as of Oct 2026.

The occasional letter

One short email when a phone worth knowing about comes out. Unsubscribe any time.

Sign up for the newsletter

Privacy